Reppu

Legend
  • Posts

    962
  • Joined

  1. Y... you're in Pocket D.

    Oh my god.
  2. Quote:
    Originally Posted by Trilby View Post
    Do, how would you SO slot Rain of Arrows? My friend wants to know, I said 2 damage, 2 recharge, an accuracy and an endurance.
    You PROBABLY don't need the Endurance in it, and Rain of Arrows has a massive Base Accuracy as well, because you will almost always do Aim > Build Up > Rain of Arrows. Thusly, I'd personally slot it, with SO's, 3 Damage, 3 Recharge.
  3. Quote:
    Originally Posted by Black_Assassin View Post
    Cheers im interested in a new plant domi now and havent tried dark assault yet and since Phillips wont believe us on the carrion creepers front...well...i can live with that i think
    I strongly support it. I had a lot of fun when I seriously played it, and still do when I go back to it when I'm feeling like utterly decimating everything ever.
  4. Siiiigh. That was due to the stupid Inspiration Box glitch. My Inspiration Box is generally near my powers. My apologies for 'hiding' my Set Bonuses, too. Would you like my Mids Build? I simply didn't bother to know where the cut happen ( I was actually hiding my cat window because people I have having conversations with do not need to be subject to your debauchery).

    You have a lot of nitpicking. And lost anyway.

    PS: I keep Auto Powers from showing up anyway, so you wouldn't see any of that. Sorry? You're not worth totally altering my UI Set up for.


    Attack Chain for Dark Assault: Midnight Grasp > Smite > Gloom > Dark Blast is what I run. I'd love to get another Smite in there but it's not possible. GLOOM IS TOO FAST. Opt Drain Life over Dark Blast if your HP is below 100%.

    In fact, I have the desire to derail this thread entirely and now only discuss other things. Let us discuss attack chains, Ponies, and Candy.
  5. Also, sorry. You wanted to play Criteria, I played Criteria in return.

    Also, by swapping out of Clarion, unless you eat a Break Free every few seconds, you can no longer do Malta or Carnies, ontop of losing other aspects, and as well you probably greatly endanger yourself in other fields (AV and GM soloing). You sacrificing MUCH more than I do.

    Did it for you. btw.



    Cut it down to make it not stretch the damned forum.

    Edit: I think that's the Farming Mode build, too, considering the lack of Venus. Eh, I dunno. Too lazy to double check that.
  6. Quote:
    Originally Posted by TwoHeadedBoy View Post
    See, you say "far better" on subjective matters. There is no "better" way to take and absorb an alpha strike. Once it's absorbed and taken, it's absorbed and taken.

    You can solo Malta and Carnies "far easier"? Well I bet you can, on your character. Just like it'd be easier for me on MY character. Subjective reasoning once again.

    "Sleet beats Drain Psyche as a debuff" is subjective also. Let's see if Sleet is enough of a debuff for you to solo a GM without any outside damage sources.

    Sure, you'll be better at controlling, but unlike you, there is nothing on the list that I CAN'T do. The rest is all just your opinion vs. my opinion. Unfortunately since there seems to be criteria that you do not meet at all, you are not a viable contender.

    Of course, now I don't even know if you have a Dominator at all! You have established a track record of fabricating characters. For all I know this Dominator does not exist either.
    Please let me know if you can do the other points, quoted for you.

    Quote:
    Originally Posted by Reppu View Post

    -Capable of increasing party Defense, Resistance, Regen, and Endurance Gain ontop of everything else.

    -Two tools of Self-Healing outside of Inspirations.

    -Minimum Soft-capped Defense with out the use of Inspirations.

    -Does not waste Destiny on Clarion.

    -Does not waste Inspiration Slots on Break Frees.

    -Has numerous additional bodies to soak up the alpha, providing many more layers of defense not only for myself, but for the party as a whole due to further decreased risk of the enemy even acknowledging them as an attack target.


    Are you capable of this? I'm willing to trade gimmicky GM soloing and maybe 30 minutes to an hour slower 1-50 Farm Speed for all of the above.
    Also, you can log on Virtue right now and I can sit infront of you with my Plant/Dark/Ice. Let me know when is good for you.
  7. Quote:
    Originally Posted by TwoHeadedBoy View Post
    Hmmm. So to summarize:

    -Your Dominator CANNOT solo GM's.
    -Your Dominator CANNOT compete with my Blaster's AOE.


    All that you have left is beating me out against an AV. Even if you're able to do that, it would seem that you are the only dishonest poster in this thread. You have argued that an imaginary Dominator you do not even have is better than my Blaster, while concealing the fact that your own Dominator is unable to do the things that my Blaster can do.

    I do not appreciate your misleading statements and your attempts to discredit me through nonexistant characters. I also do not appreciate your asserting the superiority of a character that you do not even have when it comes to accomplishing feats that I have actually accomplished. It is underhanded and dishonest.
    -Solo Giant Monsters. No temp powers or outside +dmg boosts, including Inspirations. And no Lore/Patron pets. | Cannot be done, admittedly. Or can it? Let me test this if I ever care. Can someone get me average GM Regen per second?

    -Solo 2 level 54 AV's at a time with the same restrictions as the above-mentioned. | Done it.

    -Solo Task Forces, including Master of ITF. | Done it.

    -Farm as fast or faster than any other high end farming build. Power-level farming included, 1-50 in around the 2 hour mark. | Will probably be slower, but not by enough of a margin to be noteworthy.

    -Solo enemy groups such as Carnies and Malta on 54x8. | Can do it easier. FAR easier.

    -Mass-control entire 54x8 spawns, providing mitigation for teammates. | FAR better.

    -Take and absorb alpha strikes single-handedly, providing a cushion for teammates. | FAR FAR better.

    -Permanently debuff hard single targets, making it easier for everyone in your party to accomplish a goal. | Sleet beats Drain Psyche as a debuff. Also all the ToHit debuffs. And everything is PermaConfused and killing themselves. Or busy beating up Tentacles.


    That is what I am disputing, now, for Plant/Dark/Ice. NOW, let us add the following as well:

    -Capable of increasing party Defense, Resistance, Regen, and Endurance Gain ontop of everything else.

    -Two tools of Self-Healing outside of Inspirations.

    -Minimum Soft-capped Defense with out the use of Inspirations.

    -Does not waste Destiny on Clarion.

    -Does not waste Inspiration Slots on Break Frees.

    -Has numerous additional bodies to soak up the alpha, providing many more layers of defense not only for myself, but for the party as a whole due to further decreased risk of the enemy even acknowledging them as an attack target.


    Are you capable of this? I'm willing to trade gimmicky GM soloing and maybe 30 minutes to an hour slower 1-50 Farm Speed for all of the above.
  8. Quote:
    Originally Posted by TwoHeadedBoy View Post
    I see you have yet to even try to refute my theory that your Dominator does not exist. I can think of no other reason for your bold assertion of superiority paired with your unwillingness to prove any of your points! Have you fabricated this Dominator of yours? Have you actually achieved any of the things you claim to be so much better at? Or have you simply been asserting that your spreadsheets are better than my spreadsheets?
    Yes. I have done all of this. It was my successful ploy to your logic. Now, let me correct you...

    When did I ever say this was MY Dominator? My Dominator is Plant/DARK/Ice. I trade Drain Psyche for a superior AoE and Single Target game. Immensely superior. And I'd argue it might be superior, except for GM Killing, since not having Drain Psyche is very painful, but Dark boasts vastly superior ST Damage in it's attack chain, and a superior AoE.

    I never once claimed, despite your attempts to deface my argument, my chosen Dominator was Plant/Psi/Ice. I was just capable of providing irrefutable logic and math that the combination can do EVERYTHING besides two aspects that your Blaster does, better.

    You cannot deny this, except you can ignorantly claim that "Well MINE exists and yours is theoretical so HAHAHA I win", but no. This doesn't work in City of Heroes.

    Now, if I were to compare Plant/Dark/Ice to your build, well.

    1) I have a FAR superior Attack Chain for Single Target Damage.
    2) I have the superior AoE over Psychic Shockwave in Engulfing Darkness.
    3) I lose in GM Killing Speed due to no inherent -Regen, from Drain Psyche. AV is a YMMV aspect, however. Not all AVs have high levels of Regen to abuse their HP pools off of.

    Would I race you in, say, Farm Speed? No. I don't do Speed Farming. I'm not interested in it. Am I capable of it? Sure, I do it. But it's not fun to me.

    Would I race you in AV kill speed? No. I'm not interested in racing you. You're too much of a prat still.

    Would I race you in GM kill speed? I'd lose this race because you don't allow temporary powers, so no. It's not worth racing.

    The changes between Dark vs. Psi is that Dark trades the -Regen, which is relevant on GMs and... GMs, for superior ST and AoE. It's a more than fair trade off. It also gets a +DMG power, which is decent.

    So, yes. I DO have a Plant/Dark/Ice, which I argue is competitive as well. Drain Psyche is a great power, but it's primary use as a GM Killer isn't required as soloing GMs isn't that big of a deal (other ATs Do It Better), and it's survivability use, while noteworthy, is a comprehensive comparison in use vs. Dominator hard CC and soft CC from numerous -ToHit debuffings.

    So, there you go. I do not have what I never claimed I have, but I have what I do claim I have.

    And it's sexy. And pink.

    And you're a Screwdriver.

    Quote:
    Originally Posted by Dechs Kaison View Post
    I'll offer a solution that doesn't involve transfers.

    You can each PL one of my characters on your respective home servers. I'll time both journeys. I'll even use characters I have no interest in playing so that I have no benefit to the process.
    I could probably compete easily with Plant/Dark/Ice. Again, it has better AoE than /Psi, and Drain Psyche isn't needed in farming. Will I do this, though? No. I'm not interested. I'm not here to dispute in-game performance. I'm not a Farmer. I don't play on Freedom for that reason.

    I'm simply providing numerical evidence countering his claims. Ones he cannot dispute. He simply chooses to ignore this and focus on his Farm Time and Burst Damage.

    ... And didn't I say he probably out-farms a Dominator anyway? I swear I keep doing this. I am NOT disputing this fact.
  9. Quote:
    Originally Posted by Leo_G View Post
    Hmm, how much are your ERP rates?
    Varies depending on your individual scenario involved! They apply random multipliers.

    I take my Engaging Roleplay seriously.

    Quote:
    Originally Posted by TwoHeadedBoy View Post
    Oh, now I have to prove my worth to you? And you expect me to pay you when you are the one claiming to be my superior? Nice logic.
    Yes.
  10. Quote:
    Originally Posted by TwoHeadedBoy View Post
    Haha, nice excuses. I see that you are very good at talking, but are unwilling to back up your talk. This to me is not a very good trait. You claim to be my superior and yet when you are asked to prove it, you offer nothing but excuses. I would not be surprised if this super Dominator of yours did not actually even exist.
    I'm sorry, but you have yet to provide evidence of your own accomplishments. I have requested videos of your exploits to provide a comparative analysis of how they compare to your major tangent of being superior to: SS/Fire/MuORSoul Brutes. Please provide this evidence that you are superior in all given fields above them, and perhaps I will consider you worthy of my challenge.

    Please have the videos and the $20 USD ready. As well as your 1-50 in 2 hours video.
  11. Quote:
    Originally Posted by StratoNexus View Post
    It should be noted that the dominator will only have 40 more HPs (while Hoarfrost is active and it can't be made perma, so it will have downtime during which the blaster will have more HPs (likely a fair amount more)) and the regen cap means the dom will only exceed the blaster by ~300% regen saturated.
    While Hoarfrost is active:
    10 targets for DP: 133.9 hp/s for the dom vs. 112.2 hp/sec for the blaster. Not an insignificant difference, but also not nearly as large as you try to make it out.

    Even at lower saturation points, say 5 targets the difference is not huge: 79.97 hp/sec for the dom vs. 63.14 hp/sec.
    Fair enough, but it's still a difference one can't just shrug off. Ontop of the Burst Heal, when needed and off cooldown.
  12. Quote:
    Originally Posted by TwoHeadedBoy View Post
    That's funny, because all you have done is post long-winded math rants without any accounts of in-game experience. I will happily compete with you on Freedom server in both AV and AOE speed races. We can make it into a triathlon if you'd like to suggest a third event.
    Sorry, but I'm not really interested in racing you. You see, there's one problem with me doing that; even if I won, I'm not in the position to want to gloat about it. You're not worth that time or effort. You'd just pull a ham-fisted excuse out, and continue your insane level of gloating and superiority-ignorant claims.

    Unless you'd like to pay me $20 USD to do the character transfers to Freedom, since I play on the "Parenthesis Server", and refuse to use my free tokens to transfer to you, maybe I'll consider it. But then again, I still don't care enough.

    Math is the name of City of Heroes. Math is how we know everything we do, end all be all. Application is important, as it provides a bit of leeway for Randomness, but let's face facts here; it is a game of numbers, and it's one you choose to be ignorant against.

    I will not race you, even if you come to my home server. You have taken enough precious seconds of my life, and you continue to be ignorant. Someone else can bother with this, as I do not see the 'fun' in racing people. I farm people for fun. I do it for free. I refuse to be paid for it. Thusly, I do not take it seriously and do it at my own pace.

    To put me in an uncomfortable, unfun enviroment? You'd win because I'd get bored and fall asleep halfway through.

    AV Soloing? Eh, I wouldn't even need to do Plant/Psi/Ice. Plant/Dark/Ice or Plant/Fire/Ice is more specialized for that. Or any true "AV Killer" Build, if you want to do AV Killing Speeds. But as a broad thing, hrm.

    Nope. Math dictates the Dominator has superior ST damage. You can't disprove that, even in a field test. Sorry. Math trumps execution in City of Heroes, even if I add a margin of error.

    But, I do suggest you check out Reppu's Resplendent Retreat!

    My rates are as follows...

    Quote:
    Arguing at someone for hours on end for no reason: Free

    Power Leveling a Friend: Free

    Roleplaying with me and being good at it in return: Free

    Having me server transfer to your home server to 'race' your ego: $20 USD and 2 Billion Influence, Win or Lose.

    Server transfering to me to 'race' your ego: 2 Billion Influence, Win or Lose.

    Calling TBH a Phillips Head Screwdriver, because he is the definition of one: I pay you 1 Peso.
    Please let me know if any of this interests you!
  13. Quote:
    Originally Posted by TwoHeadedBoy View Post
    I feel like you're one of those people who sits around and looks at averages without much experience of how things actually play out in game. These weaknesses that you're trying so hard to math yourself into pointing out are really not present. I have played with Plant/Psi Dominators before and they are not as epic as your spreadsheets might lead you to believe. I have outlived a great variety of Dominators on my Blaster. Player ability and familiarity with a character on top of a solid build needs to be accounted for. You seem like you play the game theoretically and assume that whatever is on your spreadsheets is the ultimate truth. While I think that it is important to make your characters solid from a numerical perspective, that alone is not as "be all, end all" as you seem to think.
    Sorry you feel that way. But since you cannot prove the other facts of your "This is what makes me superior" are better than the Dominator, and insist that your potentially superior Burst Damage/Farm Speed means you win... haha no.

    I declare officially Plant/Psi/Ice is the One Build To Rule Them All, on account of being superior in almost every field but Farm Speed (arguable).

    Thread over, ladies and gentlemen. Get your refunds at the door.
  14. Quote:
    Originally Posted by TwoHeadedBoy View Post
    When I was playing my s/l softcapped build, I needed to use the Core epiphany version since I'd get slammed with mez otherwise. Having all this positional defense means that most of the time I'm able to get through the downtime and it's worth the tradeoff when I do get hit. I obviously still keep a break free macro for emergencies, but it's been worthwhile. I haven't recorded any x8 videos because I only have 2.5 gb of ram right now. Running Fraps with all that action going on means I have to turn my particle count way down, it looks icky and it's still kinda choppy. As soon as I do some upgrading, more videos will come.
    Wait, it's not Permanent Clarion? That means you have to wait 30 seconds or mix your tray with Break Frees AND Purples?

    That is a massive weakness you didn't let me account for. When it comes to those two enemy groups, you fall back even further.
  15. Quote:
    Originally Posted by TwoHeadedBoy View Post
    You are an angry person, I see that I have thoroughly rustled your feathers. You can call me whatever you'd like, but I do not believe that you have an applicable understanding of how I play my Blaster. Rain of Arrows is not competing with my single target attack chain for Aim+Concentration time. I am either fighting large mobs and using Rain of Arrows, or I am fighting a hard single target and using my ST attacks. At the end of a spawn, when all that remains are a couple of bosses, I can hit either aim, concentration or both and quickly dispatch the last boss or two. I do not know why you think I can only use my +dmg boosts for one thing or another. They are not competing with each other.

    I think it's just silly that you don't think Aim and Concentration are even worth acknowledging. You are clearly very thick and prejudiced since your own character lacks these wonderful tools. You are also of the opinion that having Barrier means that your part time and fast diminishing damage resistance is somehow comparable to having respectable resistance to the three most common types at all times.

    I suppose you think that the absence of a target cap on Creepers is worth more than Rain of Arrows three times a minute. This is a matter of personal preference I suppose, and so there is no right and wrong. I do not think that your single target damage is as superior as you seem to think it is. I am doing more raw ST damage than you without taking any sort of +dmg boosts into account. You have a steady ~63% damage boost. I have an almost identical boost about 50% of the time, and a 100% boost the other 50% of the time. You can twist your logic and averages as much as you want, this is the most simple and clear way of looking at it though.
    ... That is not how averages work, Screwdriver. You're looking at front-loaded values by not applying how they work due to not being Permanent Buffs. Again, Build Up at the 400% Recharge Cap is worth roughly +15% Permanent Global Damage, and Aim is half that. This is slightly less because you suffer from a Recharge Dependent Action. This is how City of Heroes works. You can't ignore it because it makes your build look worse.

    You're also still ignoring Sleet, which is a permanent -30% Resistance and Defense Debuff (Yes, it is Perma), and a potential -20% Additional Resistance on top of that with IOing and a bit of 'luck'. Face it, the Dominator is either Winning, or Equal, to your Single Target. IGNORING Carrion Creepers and Venus, because you have a Pet Stigma (And an irrational one, as it only serves to play your build as Superior.)

    If I want to get even MORE technical, the Plant/Psi/Ice goes even beyond it's own HP limits! Carrion Creepers is an endless wave of aggro-grabbing bodies, providing a cushion of 1064 HP per Vine spawned, with a 50% Chance to spawn additionally on use and every 10 seconds! If you're at a 18 Cap Limit, that's going to average out to an additional 9576 Soaking HP for the Dominator, every 10 seconds.

    Every. Ten. Seconds.

    You can't even begin to compare to that, let alone the fact they are providing constant explosive AoE Proc damage and their own innate damage, above everything else.

    You have no comparison to literally spawning +10k HP every 10 Seconds for yourself. Which goes above the target cap due to the individual Bushes and Vines having their own whims.

    Delicious.

    Oh, and Venus is another +1067 HP, so it's more like 11k.

    Please look at my previous post for Defense/Resistance/HP numbers you asked for. They're delightful.

    OH, and keep in mind; Double your Regen due to superior Drain Psyche ontop of the superior HP.

    Edit: Sorry, 1071 HP per vine/Venus. Too lazy to edit all of those.
  16. First, your definition of 'trolls' is flawed. I am calling you a Screwdriver, a Phillips Head Screwdriver specifically, because you are acting like a superiority-driven prat. The Phillips Head Screwdriver was once known as one of the greatest inventions ever, but then it get replaced by more secure, superior types of screws and is thusly a relic of the past.

    Much like your build and your logic. This is not an 'insult' in so much it is an applicable title. I am not trolling you, you are just labeling yourself, Screwdriver. If you do not wish to be called Screwdriver, do not act like a Phillips Head Screwdriver, THB.

    And really, go look up the definition of 'trolling'. I do not think it means what you think it means, honey.

    Back to the debate.

    I already calculated it for you. At Maximum Global Recharge + Maximum Slotted Recharge, Concentration averages to a permanent +15% Damage Boost, and Aim to a +7.5% Damage Boost, if used every milisecond they are off cooldown. This drops slightly due to your redraw. Since you are not remotely near the recharge cap, it's not even worth acknowledging at this point. This is what we call 'Averages', THB.

    If you want to continue on your Burst Damage Hype, which you seem obsessed with, you're correct. +150% Damage from Concentration and Aim beats the Dominator out. EXCEPT you already used them when you used Rain of Arrows, and it's not a permanency. It averages out to less than +15% Global Damage with your Recharge saturation levels combined with your redraw. I'm probably slightly off on that, but applicable. And again, that is ONLY if you do not use most of the buff time on Rain of Arrows. If you do, it's worth EVEN LESS.

    Again, I already said you have Superior Burst Damage. This is one aspect of the whole. You PROBABLY win at farm times and you win at burst damage. The Dominator pulls ahead on Single Target Fights (And in all of your other listed categories, teehee!) and, again, has a unique perk you CANNOT duplicate; Can go above the Target Cap due to Carrion Creepers. You CANNOT do this. Ever. You are limited to your Hard Cap while Carrion Creepers breaks this. And provides numerous bodies that can tank further damage.

    So while you're soloing +4x8, a Dominator is theoretically capable of doing +4xAsManyEnemiesOnTheScreenAsPossible due to Carrion Creepers.

    Tragic, I know.


    Note: I did remove the 'superiority complex' jab in that quoted post when I realized it did come off as a little harsh, but you're free to keep it quoted for the sake of permanency. Just because I removed it, doesn't mean it wasn't a true statement. I just don't wish to bog my posts down with 'trolling' you, in your skewed definition of the word. I'm here to debunk your claim of being the One Build To Rule Them All. You do one thing better than another build, which does everything else better AND does more.

    Your build is probably one of the Rings of Men, while Plant/Psi/Ice is the One Ring, with a coating of Bacon. Delicious and Superior.


    Edit: S/L Resistance is at 25% Perma with Barrier, but is obviously higher than that on Average. Cold is at 30%. Fire is at 13.5%. Toxic is at 17.8% The other resistances are at 5% Perma. Again, this is ignoring Tier 4 Barrier Averages But you're ignoring the fact Hoarfrost is putting the Dominator at the HP Cap with, not a permanent upkeep, but nigh-perma. One can survive with out their HP Cap for a couple of spawns just fine.

    Your Energy Resistance comes into play during Trials, and your S/L is a constant in farming I assume. You have twice the S/L (Less, really. We're ignoring Averages), but you have far less HP, do not have a self heal (Hoarfrost doubles), and you are at risk of CDB.
  17. Woah now, buddy. You're forgetting things again. I know being a Phillips Head Screwdriver is difficult because interchangable heads exist, but let's not be narrow.

    1) You forgot to acknowledge the Dominator ATO Proc, a permanent 63.75% Damage Bonus. You would slot this into Subdue from Psi Assault, allowing you not only a good attack (Better than lol Entangle), but, you know, a permanent 63.75% +DMG.

    In fact, you largely ignored the secondary almost entirely. Let me correct you.

    Subdue: 86.64 vs. 52.55 from Snap Shot

    Mental Blast: 86.64 vs. 161.7 from Blazing Arrow

    Mind Probe: 114.4 vs. 91.2 on your Mind Probe

    That's a bit more realistic on Dominator ST Attack chains. And yes, that chain is possible. So, keeping that in mind, and once the third rotation goes you have a 63.75% Permanent Damage Boost... Subdue and Mental Blast gain an additional 57.X DPA at base value, and Mind Probe gains 72.X And yes, I am counting this bonus because it's a permanent number, unlike Build Up + Aim. This is acceptable, yes?

    This then becomes, on Third Rotation and Beyond...

    Subdue: 143.64 vs. 52.55 from Snap Shot

    Mental Blast: 143.64 vs. 161.7 from Blazing Arrow

    Mind Probe: 186.4 vs. 91.2 on your Mind Probe

    No complaints, right? It's a permanent damage boost that takes less then 10 seconds to ramp into permanency. You should be able to agree with this.

    Hrm.

    I'm under the impression the Dominator wins by a landside in Single Target Attack Chains. You get a boost in Aim and Concentration, BUT, BUT BUT BUT, you're using more than half of that during Rain of Arrows, and it's not a permanency. In fact, I think it equals to about a global, at MAXIMUM RECHARGE (Hint: You're no where near this), 15% Damage Boost 'permanent' from Build Up if you're always using it (lowered due to your redraw), and Aim is half that at 7.5% or so (lowered due to your redraw).

    While you do benefit as well from your Inherent Power, which in your given chain is 6.6% from Snap Shot, 7.7% from Mind Probe, and 12.1% from Blazing Arrow, you're still not touching the monstrous 63.75% of the Dominator.

    And we're ignoring Sleet, which is an additional permanent -30% Resistance, and if you proc it, that's -50%!

    The Dominator also has a Type Advantage in nearly every scenario, with Psionic being seldom resisted outside of choice enemy groups (which you will not willingly fight outside of trials). So, there's even more calculations to uphold!

    And, really? Tier 4 Barrier is only good for Ten Seconds? Try 60 seconds, with the last 60 seconds still providing +5% global Defense and Resistance. Sorry. You lose on the Incarnate Power front from needing Clarion, while the Dominator has the utmost freedom to pursue any other.

    Note: TKThrust beats Mental Blast in DPA, it's slower and not everyone likes a Mag 16 KB.

    Note #2: This was ignoring Carrion Creepers, who provide more damage than one would initially think, and can't 'die' so they are legal in your 'pets department'. I am willing to argue that Venus should also count, as it's a Primary Set Power, but /shrug.
  18. Again, you go RIGHT back to the farming point and nothing else, Screwdriver. One-Headed Screwdriver, even! This is not winning you ANY points. I already said you probably have the faster farm speed, but lose on every other point which you happily ignore.

    Let me correct you: The Dominator does NOT rely on Seeds of Confusion. Even if a single application misses, due to having Destiny Rebirth or Destiny Barrier over Destiny Clarion, they have either superior total health or superior Defense/Wide (AKA: Not S/L/E, but global) Resistance. So even though you are spouting "Well the S/L Softcap means NOTHING ;_;", let me note the following; You aren't farming Malta or Carnies, so it's irrelevant.

    In a designated farm designed to play your strengths, you fight what you are strong against. This means the Dominator would be duking it out with S/L mobs. And even then, since we'll be applying your same logic, Destiny Barrier + a Purple = Doing what you do. Your SOLE Advantage is your superior Resistance numbers, BUT the Dominator will hit the S/L Incarnate Soft Cap, rendering them further immune to Cascading Debuff Failure shenanigans, AND has Hoarfrost. You do not have anything remotely comparable to Hoarfrost.

    Moving on to my original note, Seeds of Confusion is one tool in the arsenal. Sleet is one of the other dominate tools, not to mention Psychic Shockwave's additional AoE, and Carrion Creeper Explosions. Which not only provide multiple bodies to be targeted over you, but their AoE damage is absolutely silly when slotted properly.

    The Dominator IS doing an extremely high amount of AoE damage, but I will agree not as high as your Burst AoE with Rain of Arrows. Does this matter? Probably only if you absolutely need everything to die right now this very instant. The Dominator isn't quite as concerned with as many RNG factors as your Blaster is when it comes to "How long do I have to wait until I can faceroll?"

    Now, let's go toward the one other thing you noted; Seeds of Confusion causing gains to be less. This is so amateur it makes me sad. We've got years of research proving the additional killspeed given by Seeds of Confusion, combined with a Dominator being able to hit the benchmark damage needed to mitigate losses of Seeds of Confusion, greatly out-weighs the scant losses in 'immediate XP/Prestige/Influence/ gain.

    But, again, I am not arguing your superiority in specific farming. You can keep that. It's not even a grand title. Brutes arguably do it better still anyway. I am arguing every other point, which you insist in ignoring.

    Your Burst Damage: Rain of Arrows, Psychic Shockwave
    Dominator Burst Damage: Carrion Creeper Explosion, Seeds of Confusion Alphas, Psychic Shockwave.

    Just to note that the Dominator Burst IS there, all things said.

    But, I'm arguing a point I do not need to argue; We'll say for the sake of argument you can do 1-50 somewhat faster than the Dominator. Let's give you that point and that point alone, for now.

    Disprove the rest, please?
  19. If something can do the majority of aspects you list, better, it is a trivialization of your accomplishments. Does it make them less amazing? Not particularly, but the problem lies with the following as well; You continue to ignore the point.

    My apologies to your build, but it has nothing amazing going for it outside of Rain of Arrows, which is the only reason people play Archery from a mechanic point of view. Mental Manipulation is known predominantly for Drain Psyche, and a secondary of Psychic Shockwave. World of Confusion has limited application but it has it's moments.

    You are being carried by Rain of Arrows and Drain Psyche, powers wise. Your individual skill may play party to the plot, but largely enough you already explained your combat method; Keep everything stacked together with Fences, keep yourself alive with the layered defenses + Using a Purple Inspiration to remain Soft Capped (How come you can use Purple Inspirations but using Red Inspirations is against the rules? Again, you're playing this to your specific advantage, which is ludicrous.), destroy with Rain of Arrows.

    Rinse, Repeat. Nothing changes.

    My stance, that I have detailed in my post, that you ignored because a Phillips Head Screwdriver is only capable of doing one singular task and nothing more, is that the Plant/Psi/Cold (or Fire) Dominator can do the majority of your tasks, better. But possibly, POSSIBLY cannot do one better. It all depends on a few aspects.

    As for the individual who plays a Plant/Psi/Cold and says they probably (note probably, you're being a Screwdriver again with your narrowing), can't beat your run time on a GM. That's all they said. I disagree, because Drain Psyche is what allows you to solo a GM. This was proven in that debauchery of a thread you posted before. /Psi dominators have twice the base value power in their Drain Psyche, ontop of Sleet, and an arguably superior damage chain. Not to mention their pets, which ARE legal because a Dominator has the tools to sustain them. Perhaps not the Fly Trap, but there are ways to manipulate the field to the Dominator's advantage.

    I think the joke here, besides the fact you are so adamant against being wrong and dismiss everything you possibly can, is that you set so many ham-fisted rules to defend yourself that you, at least in an illusionary attempt, made it 'impossible' to be contested. Yet I already have done so, and you continue to shrug it off as 'vindictive'.

    If you are going to insist Rain of Arrows and Drain Psyche are not the main tools of your kit, you are free to demonstrate a run with their use minimalized to instead focus predominately on the other tools of your kit, which are, by your own words, Electric Fences, World of Confusion, and Psychic Shockwave.

    In doing so, you will prove Rain of Arrows and Drain Psyche are simply different heads to your adjustable Screwdriver. However, we can stop here and know, for a fact, this is an impossibility. Archery survives off Rain of Arrows. Mental Manipulation lives predominately on Drain Psyche, with Psychic Shockwave being a good power, and World of Confusion being a niche power.

    There is nothing wrong with a Phillips Head Screwdriver, but you shouldn't be as narrow-sighted as it is narrow in application.
  20. Quote:
    Originally Posted by Leo_G View Post
    Sooo....nerf Doms?
    Totally.
  21. Quote:
    Originally Posted by Oedipus_Tex View Post
    Well I am somewhat guilty of falling into THB's trap. He seems like a likable enough guy, just some of his views are kind of odd. I think his Blaster build is actually quite good, I just wish he would present it with a little more humility and be more forthcoming about its faults.

    The fact is, every time he posts a build, I feel like I'm looking at the cover of Cosmo. His posts seem to say Isn't this the hottest woman you've ever seen? and I want to write, Actually that's the lead singer from the Black Eyed Peas after Photoshop.

    Not to nitpick too hard, but I remind you that the person who is claiming this build offers significant control also recently posted a Controller build that lacked its single target hold. I could have let that go for anyone else, but in this case it's too relevant to the discussion to ignore.




    I don't want to verify specific claims about Plant Dominators, but one additional item for the list: the Plant Dom gets Drain Psyche and Destiny: Barrier, because it doesn't have to rely on Destiny: Clarion for mezz protection.
    I noted that in terms of the option, or the HP Cap you can theoretically hit with Hoarfrost, Accolades, and Destiny Rebirth. But Destiny Barrier is likely the superior alternative. Regardless, Dominators get many, many more options, and do his Wide Crowd Control infinitely better with a Mag 6 AoE Confusion that also takes his precious proc.
  22. Quote:
    Originally Posted by TwoHeadedBoy View Post
    Fascinating rant! I see that you are also making the claim that you can accomplish all the same feats on your Dominator. I'd be curious to know more about yours also. Unfortunately, I can't in good conscience reply to the rest of your post since it is inflammatory by nature. You are predisposed to criticize, which is truly a shame. You are the kind of person who sees greatness and then picks at it. I suppose if you ever met a real life super hero while they rescued you from a burning building, you would accuse them of not being able to do it fast enough. You might also reference other super heroes who could do it just as well, theoretically speaking, without any personal claim that's anywhere near as remarkable. People like you are why I felt the need to create the rules in this thread.
    You're just making really poor excuses to skirt around the issue. You're bragging about your accomplishments, but what you fail to realize is people do aspects of your own, better. Here, let me break it down a bit.

    -Solo Giant Monsters. No temp powers or outside +dmg boosts, including Inspirations. And no Lore/Patron pets. | /Psi grants Drain Psyche, with TWICE THE BASE POWER, which is what you use to solo Giant Monsters. A Plant/Psi/Ice has superior Single Target damage, so they will do it faster as well. Point goes to the Dominator.

    -Solo 2 level 54 AV's at a time with the same restrictions as the above-mentioned. | /Psi grants Drain Psyche, /-/Ice grants Sleet, which provides another layer of debuffing. Additionally, Confusion will grant the Dominator a lot of leeway to not only solo the 2 AVs, but also have them getting torn apart by their little dogs, too. Point goes to the Dominator.

    -Solo Task Forces, including Master of ITF. | Easily, doubly so because the Dominator has a Confusion. Point goes to the Dominator.

    -Farm as fast or faster than any other high end farming build. Power-level farming included, 1-50 in around the 2 hour mark. | You actually probably need to prove this one. I am not sure if a Plant/Psi/Ice can do this, but this is definitely the one thing you definitely need to prove that you're capable of doing. In fact, what IS the general method for 1-50 in 2 hours? I'll try to duplicate it on my own Dominator if I knew the actual nitty-gritty method. But, since you can't prove this, and I obviously can't, neither point is awarded.

    -Solo enemy groups such as Carnies and Malta on 54x8. | Seeds of Confusion. Beyond that? Sleet, Carrion Creepers, Drain Psyche. Point to the Dominator because they can do it with out any risk at all, period. You have to rely 100% on Rain of Arrows, the Dominator has at minimum three different tools to shut these groups down, permanently.

    -Mass-control entire 54x8 spawns, providing mitigation for teammates. | Seeds of Confusion, Carrion Creepers, Roots, Mass AoE Damage, Etc Etc. Dominator Point.

    -Take and absorb alpha strikes single-handedly, providing a cushion for teammates. | Seeds of Confusion, Carrion Creepers, Sleet, Mass AoE Damage, Drain Psyche, Soft-Capped due to Ice Mastery, HP Capped due to Ice Mastery and Accolades and Rebirth. Point Dominator.

    -Permanently debuff hard single targets, making it easier for everyone in your party to accomplish a goal. | Drain Psyche, Sleet. You can't compare. Point Dominator.



    You lose in every case aside maybe the 1-50 Farm, which you need to prove.

    Note: I am well aware you get World of Confusion's Mag 2, and sometimes Proc'd, confusion. Dominators get a Mag 6, sometimes proc, confusion. It doesn't compare. Ontop of every other form of CC you mentioned, and magnitudes more. Don't even contest this, because you will lose the moment you try.
  23. I know you said you aren't trying to brag... but you are bragging, in the end. And most of your posts responding to anyone who points this out, or flaws in your "To Rule Them All" criteria, you respond with either snark, or just being flat-out insulting. It doesn't really do you any justice, if your attempts are to even do that.

    We all know Drain Psyche is what carries you through everything. We're also all well aware Drain Psyche is an obscenely powerful ability that needs to be adjusted (at the very least it's scaling -Regen that breaks traditional -Regen debuffing).

    The problem with your criteria, however, is that it doesn't go into specifics. Little details inbetween, aside from what it comes from your speed in farming.

    How fast is your GM Kill Speed? (Hint: 24 Minute Video?)

    How fast is your 1/2 AV Kill Speed?

    How fast is your Master of ITF or whichever ITF?

    And so on and so on.

    While your build may be capable of these feats, you only put emphasis on your strengths, and scoff and claim troll at anyone who attempts to point out your weaknesses, or the comparative numbers needed.

    For example; a Plant/Psi/Ice or Fire Or Whatever Dominator may not have your AoE Farming Kill Speed (May not, as unlike you, a Plant Dom CAN artificially go above the target cap your Rain of Arrows if set to), they are more than likely, with out a doubt, terribly TERRIBLY out-speeding you on anything that involves singular or multiple tough opponents (The GM or AV challenges.)

    Thusly, if you're going to brag, which you are, post videos demonstrating your prowess. A call of 'put up or shut up', if you will. Do not claim what you do, prove what you do. But I believe you did that once, and people went 'lololololthattookyouHOWlong?" or something.
  24. >Ask for advice on how to build for better damage.

    >Told to slot/keep Tornado because it does immense damage.

    >Drop tornado, ignore advice, doing far less damage.

    Ffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffff!
  25. Quote:
    Originally Posted by Aura_Familia View Post
    Sooo you'rte making my point, that the alignment system developed in GR was pointless? That you can just pick any random choice in the options presented and it has no bearing on whether you become a hero or villain?

    good to know.
    It's called 'roleplaying', which is all it was ever going to effect in an 8 year old system.

    Quit your complaining.