-
Posts
7232 -
Joined
-
Quote:
Taser works fine as it is, although I would love the hand-held taser that Malta still have (increase duration for making it melee?
)
Erm, it used to be exactly that. It was changed after many people complained about a melee power in the only set that lets them stay out of melee completely. -
Quote:Yes, it's worth taking.OK so I guess I'm going to take Regen.
But, is Resilience worth taking? (I'm not sure if the power is actually called Resilience.. its the one that gives you minor stun protection and small resistance to smashing, lethal, and toxic.)
But the numbers are so small I don't know if its worth it. I guess if the stun protection actually helps I'll take it.
If for no other reason, it makes a good place to put a Steadfast 3% Defense IO.
Also, you can pop a wakie and have the stun wear off from it very quickly.
Not sure if it's as useful in PvP, but you still have to level the character, right? -
Superficial resemblance, mostly due to him being silver and one of the colors on the rest of his outfit being red. If you changed the black and red to, say, blue and white the resemblance would drop off quite a bit.
The fact that he's Invuln doesn't help either, especially if he is also Super Strength. I can see why people would think that he's a ripoff, though I doubt I would think the same if you ran past me.
I created a character who bears a passing similarity to Colossus myself, except mine was an Electric/Willpower brute. I used the Cyborg Cables shoulder piece to represent a charge pack that fuels his powers (he doesn't actually have any powers aside from his metal skin, it happens to be an excellent conductor while keeping him insulated, so he runs a charge through his arms to attack with) -
-
Where Durakken's argument falls flat on it's face before it ever gets out of the gate is he is basing the ENTIRE thing off the Paragon dimension being the correct one and all variations being divergent from it. He is presenting this as inarguable fact because he assumes it is true.
The only reason the Paragon universe is referred to as Prime Earth is because that is where the game takes place.
I guarantee that the denizens of all of those other realities are just as convinced that THEIR universe is the "correct" one and all the others are divergent from it.
So, in short, he is basing his argument on something he is assuming is true, when it is almost assuredly not. The Paragon reality isn't the One True Reality....it is just one of an infinite number of possibilities. We have been shown, through game lore, a very tiny slice of those possibilities and he is leaping to conclusions based on his own assumptions, which are NOT as universal as he thinks they are.
If his assumptions WERE as universal as he claims, this entire debate would have never happened because we all would have automatically agreed with him and questioned nothing. The very fact that this debate IS happening is conclusive proof that those assumptions are not automatic or universal in any way. -
-
It's completely random, or as random as a computer generated algorithm can get.
The "every 12,000 kills" is an average, not a guaranteed number. You could get 2 in a row, or you could go years without getting one. If you're over 15,000 kills, by the law of averages you're probably due for one, but that doesn't mean you'll get one.
And you don't have to fight level 50 enemies to get one, anything level 47 and up will drop them. Basically anything that can drop a level 50 common IO can drop a purple (since common IOs only come in multiples of 5, it rounds up at level 47 and down at level 46, so 46's won't drop purples) -
Except I don't think DT is a guaranteed knockdown, it's like an 80% chance or something.
-
Quote:That's Statesman's history, not Reichsman's."Born Marcus Cole, he began his transformation from a poverty born child to world hero after serving in the US Army during World War I. Instead of coming home in 1918 he headed east, bent on exploring the world now that he'd had a taste of it."
"Instead of coming home in 1918 he headed east, bent on exploring the world now that he'd had a taste of it. Where he went and what happened to him during that lost decade remains a secret to this day."
http://www.cityofheroes.com/game_inf...roduction.html
It says East or Far East
However they are looking for the fictional Greek island of Praxidae which would be south east of Germany in the Mediterranean... Maybe the clues for it led them further east and then back, either way they wouldn't have had to cross germany in that time and i doubt they would have.
Your "divergent reality" theory is assuming that all of those things happened exactly like that in every reality.
You are completely discarding the possibility that the divergence in YOUR OWN THEORY may have been prior to any of those things happening.
It is you who keeps saying that it's a divergent reality, yet you refuse to accept that the divergence happened anywhere else but where YOU say it did.
Reichsman is NOT Statesman, his life played out differently. Since his life played out differently he is the same person in genetics only. Like I said before, any number of things could have happened to cause the differences, and they could have happened before Cole was even born. Since we have been given very little information concerning Reichsman's early life, we can't assume it played out identically up to a certain point. If it DID play out identically he would be Statesman in every reality, and he is not.
Tyrant's history played out closer to Statesman's than Reichsman's did. His point of divergence seems to have been his decision to murder his best friend.
It seems far more likely that OUR Marcus Cole is the divergent one. Out of the 3 we have been shown, 2 of them are power hungry dictators, and ours is a patriotic hero. That tells me that out of all the realities in which Marcus Cole found the Well of Furies, more often than not he chooses to use the power selfishly. Most likely due to the fact that his life was not the same in every reality.
There is nothing that says he has to join the army in order to find the Well, he could have stumbled on it by accident while hiking.
There's nothing that says he even has to be American. In a multiverse with infinite possibilities it is entirely possible he was German, or French, or any other nationality. There's no guarantee America will even EXIST in any given reality.
I mean, do you really think Portal Corp has discovered and explored every reality that could possibly exist? That would be impossible in an infinite multiverse, which spins off new realities every time ANY living creature makes a decision. Every time you make a decision, new realities are created in which you did NOT make that decision. -
Okay, say it IS a divergent reality.
What if the divergence in Reichsman's world was before Marcus Cole was even born?
If Cole was raised in Germany (or raised by Stefan Richter's family in Austria perhaps?) he would have probably been on the Axis side in the first place.
Also, assuming that Marcus Cole is a good person in every possible reality is flat out foolish. The kind of person you become is largely determined by the environment you are raised in, if that dimension's version of Cole had a crappy life prior to him becoming a mercenary, chances are he wasn't a very nice guy to begin with.
Note my bolding of the word "mercenary". Mercenaries generally don't care what they do to other people, as long as they are well paid for it. If he was a mercenary to begin with in that dimension, he probably would have remained one after finding the Well. Germany just offered him the most money.
Where you fail is assuming that he was a good person who just got corrupted. Maybe in that dimension he was just a power-hungry mercenary and saw the best chance for the most gain was by allying with Germany. There is nothing that says he had to hate Jews or even care what Hitler's reasons were for anything if it gained him power.
At the beginning of the war, when Germany was crushing any country they went after, it would probably have looked pretty good to someone who was just after personal power regardless of the cost.
Reichsman lived a different life than OUR Marcus Cole, expecting him to have the exact same personality is just dumb. Any number of things could have led to him being an evil SOB, up to and including the possibility that he always was an evil SOB. -
-
Quote:Well, the game is primarily combat oriented.Only the finest green, m'man.
Was thinking claws, typed MA. Typo-slash-brainfart. My Wolvie is claws/regen though.
Made Sabes a stalker because I didn't have one, and he's sort of stalker-ish in the Weapon X stuff I read recently. Brute works. Scrapper works. WP works instead of regen. *shrug*
As for Deadpool, Tasky, Rogue, and Nightcrawler... your suggestions don't do it for me. The game just doesn't support their schticks. I don't see much point in making them if you can't model, at least to some degree, their primary abilities. To each his own though - if you want to make them, go for it.
My reasoning for Deadpool is that the pair of katanas are his signature weapon, and he seems to view his guns as disposable. And while he CAN dodge attacks, he doesn't seem to go to much effort to do so, instead letting them hit him and healing it back. The teleport mechanic actually works for him, because he uses a device to do it rather than it being an inherent ability. He can't teleport instantly like Nightcrawler can.
Every time I've seen Taskmaster lately (notably in the Siege storyline) he has been using a sword and a shield, so that's my reasoning for him.
I suppose Rogue could be a side switched SS/Invuln brute as well. But again coming back to the fact that the game is pretty much all combat I figured Invuln/SS or SS/Invuln because more often than not she'll just punch them rather than use her mutant power, since she doesn't really like having all those memories in her head if there isn't a good reason for doing it. If you really WANTED to, I suppose you could use pool powers and Epic pools to represent any powers she may have absorbed lately.
Nightcrawler DOES use sabres, and he is exceptionally agile. The teleport mechanic in CoH is way too clunky to use it in combat like he does, but otherwise he pretty much IS a DB/SR scrapper. Unless you feel he needs to use a prehensile tail in combat that would describe his combat style pretty well. -
What the **** are you smoking dude?
Wolverine is a CLAWS/REGEN scrapper. He is pretty much the reason those powersets exist in the first place. The default claws are almost identical to his.
You could make a good case for him being Claws/Willpower though, since his regeneration is completely passive.
Actually, he IS a Claws/Willpower scrapper, if you look at what the powers actually do.
Heightened Senses? Check, he actually has that EXACT power.
Mind Over Body? Smashing, Lethal and Psionic resistance. His adamantium bones give him the physical resistances, and the fact that his brain has been fried over the years gives him some resistance to psionic attacks.
Fast Healing? Duh.
Rise to the Challenge? His ferocity in combat would contribute to an accuracy debuff, and the adrenaline boost he gets does tend to speed his healing up a little.
Come to think of it, Wolverine may be a side switched brute. After all, he originally was a villain character introduced in an issue of the Hulk. And the Fury mechanic works perfectly for him.
What?Quote:Sabretooth - Claws/Regen Stalker
Sabretooth is a Claws/WP BRUTE.
Dual Blades/Regen scrapper with Teleport.Quote:Deadpool - Can't really be done
Yes, he uses guns as well, but when he's really getting down and dirty he pulls the swords out. And the Regen powerset actually makes more sense for him than for Wolverine, as he can heal himself at will.
Well, her actual mutant power can't be done, but for all practical purposes she's a flying Invuln/SS tank.Quote:Rogue - Can't really be done
Sure it can, the vast majority of the time he is a Broadsword/Shield scrapper.Quote:Taskmaster - Can't really be done
He uses a pair of sabres a lot of the time, and his only real mutant powers are teleportation and exceptional speed and reflexes. So he would be a Dual Blades/Super Reflexes scrapper with teleport.Quote:Nightcrawler - Can't really be done -
I use the scientific names of various tarantula species. My wife and I collect tarantulas (we have about 85 at the moment) so I have a large selection of names open to me.
Not one of them has EVER been taken either
-
Quote:You're only thinking of defenders here. -Range in Flash arrow would make a /TA controller pretty much invincible, since almost all of them have access to an AoE immobilize. Immobilize the mob, then Flash Arrow and pick off the enemies that can't shoot back at your leisure.No, to both. Unless you are suggesting -Range or Placate makes either Taunt or Stalkers godlike.
That kind of thing is exactly why all melee sets were given a ranged attack in AE missions, because of exploiting hoverblasting against mobs that had no ability to even attack you, much less damage you. Flash Arrow's recharge is low enough that you could permanently nullify an entire mob's ability to attack at all.
So, since they aren't going to add something to the defender version without porting the same change over to the other 3 ATs that have the set, its not going to happen.
Placate in Entangling Arrow probably isn't going to happen either. -
Quote:This.If you want softcapped defenses, you'd be much better off going with smashing/lethal instead of ranged, especially with Ice Armour.
You'll be much better protected using DP/PSW/Inferno and it's easier to softcap. Fire/MM is one of the more AoE heavy sets but if you're staying purely at range you're losing a lot of its benefits.
Drain Psyche is an awesome regen/recovery buff and you need to be in melee range to use it. Psychic Shockwave is one of the better PBAoE attacks in the game which also requires you to be in melee range.
Smashing/Lethal defense will protect you from at least as many attacks as ranged will. Gunfire, the most common ranged attack in the game, is lethal damage, and the vast majority of melee attacks have a smashing or lethal component. -
Eh....I don't really have anything else to add here, already said my piece.
But....I'm looking forward to the thread Fire-Minded starts in a month or so entitled "Why does my Claws/Invuln suck in PvP?!"
Go ahead and build what you want, but remember before you complain later that you were WARNED by multiple people and ignored what they had to say. -
-
Do you know why the Martial Arts powerset in the game is so generic and not one specific form?
I do. It's because the devs are very well aware that there are dozens (if not hundreds) of martial arts out there, and they specifically made their powerset generic so it could be applied to any backstory. They knew that if they created one specific martial arts style they would get flak from people because A) The martial artist they envisioned doesn't practice that style, or B) They got it wrong when they did the animations.
The style of martial arts I would call what they have here is "comic book martial arts". If you read a comic book, you'll notice that very rarely do they ever say that a martial artist character uses a specific style. They do that for a couple reasons:
A) the writers usually don't know much about martial arts themselves.
B) it leaves them open to allow the character to do anything they can dream up, rather than having them fight a certain way all the time. It stands to reason that you'd have to adjust your technique when fighting a person that can take an anti-tank shell to the face without even flinching.
Someone trained in only one style would probably lack the ability to deal with that person if their style doesn't teach a way to expose a weakness in someone impervious to normal attacks.
How is a kung fu master supposed to fight the Hulk?
Jujitsu isn't going to help you much against Juggernaut.
Aikido's bone-breaking techniques are going to be useless against Wolverine.
How do you grapple someone who is ON FIRE? (Human Torch)
Do YOU know how to hit the Thing's pressure points? I don't.
Try and punch Quicksilver or the Flash, I dare ya.
Comic book martial arts are generic because there isn't a technique in real life that could ever handle any of those situations, so they make stuff up. CoH martial arts are generic for the exact same reason. -
Quote:Because of the effect unlimited amounts of purchaseable influence would have on prices in the market. When you have unlimited funds you'd think nothing of spending 30 million on a Luck Charm. Some of the high end IOs are already extremely expensive, if you add the ability to buy influence directly from the game like a server transfer or rename you'd see prices skyrocket as people start placing ridiculously high bids on things because they can just buy more influence when they run out.Why do you say that?
I can go by a Bootleg of Avatar for $5 bucks, cost 5 times that to get it at Target. Just because the shady internet site selling cheap influ in large chunks doesn't mean the customer wouldn't pay twice as much for half the amount if that influence was being sold in the same place we buy server transfers, renames and respecs.
Currently prices are regulated by the fact that you have to earn the influence you're spending (among other factors). Whether it be by farming, lucky drops, or playing the market, there is an investment involved that would not exist if you could just swipe a credit card and max out your in-game money. People are more careful about how much they spend if they worked for the money they're spending, when all you did was put in your credit card information the amount you spend is less important to you.
For a real life example, look at how many lottery winners go broke within a decade of winning. From their perspective it's basically free money, so they think nothing of dropping ludicrous sums of cash on ridiculous things, and living well beyond their sustainable means (meaning they can afford to live like that only for as long as the money lasts, and then lose everything when it runs out) A millionaire who earned their money doesn't generally blow it needlessly, especially since you don't become a millionaire in the first place if you're stupid about what you spend it on. -
Quote:Fine....don't even try to fix it.Ooh thats why there over 30 pages with people posting the same problem right.
Wel looks like i just waisted 6gig of my bandwith and 20 bucks geuss wil never ever buy a game from this worhtless company again.
Im throwing this junk in the bin and thats where it ******* belongs!
Just throw a temper tantrum and throw it away, that's clearly the most reasonable solution. It is YOU having a problem with the game, NOT a problem inherent in the game.
In short, it's NOT the game's fault you're having trouble running it.
And, just for the record, hyperbole doesn't make you right. I can guarantee there aren't 30 pages of people posting the same complaint. If there were, you would have found a solution to your problem somewhere in those 30 pages, leading me to believe that you haven't even looked for a solution, instead you decided to nerdrage and blame the game for your failure to run it. -
The popular PvP sets are popular for a reason.
Invuln sucks in PvP because the power that makes it good in PvE is useless in PvP. I'm talking about Invincibility. It gives you a defense boost based on the number of foes in melee range of you. First off, defense in PvP is like hiding behind a cardboard box in a gunfight. Second, no one is going to stay in melee range with you long enough to give you any kind of boost at all. Willpower has the same problem with RttC.
Claws is a DPS set rather than a burst damage set. In order to get good damage out of Claws you need to take advantage of your low cast time/fast recharging attacks to pile on the damage. No one is going to hold still long enough to let you do that. What you end up with is low cast time attacks that don't do much damage because PvP damage is deterimined by cast time. You will be using almost nothing but Focus and Shockwave in zones because only a brute is going to enter melee with you. And a brute will punch right through Invuln and kill you most of the time.
So you have the problem of not being able to kill any ranged opponents because your burst damage sucks, and probably not killing melee opponents because your secondary isn't going to keep you alive long enough for the DPS nature of Claws to get a kill.
My Claws/Regen gets a few kills, but he has a secondary better suited for PvP. I also didn't create him specifically for PvP, he's my main and I just happen to occasionally PvP with him. If I were creating a character JUST for PvP Claws/Invuln would be near the bottom of the list of sets I would use. -
Quote:Probably for the same reason a lot of Controllers don't pair them....In order to keep the mob inside Bonfire's radius you have to keep spamming Fire Cages...that eats away at your end bar pretty quick.Is there a reason why Doms don't pair Fire Cages + Bonfire? Is it because without containment the damage is too piddly?
Well, at least that's MY reason for not doing it. I don't see a whole lot of Fire Controllers or Dominators who DO combine them, so perhaps my reasoning has merit? Or maybe it's the piddly damage thing. -
Also...unless I'm missing something somewhere...Energy Aura lacks a taunt aura. While not a problem for stalkers, brutes will definitely miss having it.
It looks, on the surface at least, as though Energy Aura was designed for stalkers, and brutes only got it when they realized Ice was going to cause problems. (I have no idea if this is true or not, but it's the only reason I can think of why a brute secondary would not have a taunt aura in it) -
Also, make sure you tell him not to delete the spines/regen. Once he gets more experienced playing scrappers in general he may come back to it and find he likes it more once he's a better player.

